This Time is Different?

In order to share current market conditions, I borrowed this title from an excellent book “This Time Is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly by Kenneth Rogoff and Carmen M Reinhart”. If you haven’t read it, I shall suggest that you get a copy and read it.

Let’s get to the business. If by June 30th, Dow can’t close above 10,130 this will be the 2nd consecutive month of downward move by Dow for the first time since March’09 bottom. Well, so what?

Before recent pullback begun, I drew a chart on NDX (Nasdaq-100). In this chart I drew a “potential” head & shoulder top pattern expecting NDX to move upto 1929 and then start to retrace (If right shoulder were to develop) and potentially touch Feb low before or by July 2010. I also shared a modified version of this chart with OPNewsletter subscriber on June 22. Well, so far NDX has retraced almost 100 points and one of our speculative trade (NDX Jul 1700/1750/1800 Put butterfly has yielded roughly +100%). The chart below was drawn after June 16th close.

The point is not about blowing my own trumpet to say our trade worked out fine, but to share with you about a potential dangerous situation that might be developing in the markets.

There was a head & shoulder pattern in May-Jul last year spanning across 2.5 months covering about 600 Dow points. The support level was around 8,240 for Dow. It broke the floor but it turned out to be a “fake” H&S breakout (hindsight bias). We have another H&S pattern developing now. You may argue, so what, the current one may turn out to be the same?

Let’s compare the two-

  • Current H&S pattern spans across almost 6 months (all marked on the chart below) and covers a massive range of almost 1500 points from the peak to the lowest point!!

  • The comparison falls pale when compared with extreme action days (90% volume days either up or down). In last two months alone, I have observed 16 extreme days that include 10 up and 6 downs days (including 2 recent 90% down days on June 22 and June 24th), the most in past 3 years.

  • Monthly stochastic is in the overbought region, and falling and about to cross to trigger a sell signal, as opposed to rising from the oversold region during the last pattern. MACD is showing pretty much the same picture.
  • On the economic front, last year we were expecting positive news 6-9months later as opposed to double dip/Euro crisis currently and every light at the end of tunnel seems to be another locomotive.
  • Last May-Jul, China was not in a bear market zone [If you didn’t know, China is already grappling with Bear (as defined by 20% or more decline from peak) and is below the level seen last July]

I don’t think there is anything else to forecast or write about except that we need to be careful. You might have noticed my cautionary tone beginning Mid April when I started saying that market requires caution and Little Johnny’s are coming to the market who are usually late comers to the party.

Neither I am not a doom’s day forecaster nor a euphoric optimistic. No hard rain is coming until unless all major indices fall and close below Feb lows. I am glad that I have suggested OPN subscribers to be out of stocks when Dow dropped below 10.3 for first time (or check my twitter streams).

BottomlineIt’s your money. Take care and trade carefully. There is no need to take unnecessary risk. When bear attacks, panic reigns, screen freezes, decision making chokes. Financial freedom is not about being invested all the time or just buy and hold (at least I don’t think that way). Cash has it own wonderful returns that allows to buy when things are cheap. Check here what does financial freedom means. Let Mr Market do the talking and show the way. I am still watching the Feb lows before concluding anything else.


4 responses to “This Time is Different?”

  1. OptionPundit Avatar

    Overall a big sell off day.

    Key Highlights-
    – Another 90% down day; volume was showered in the afternoon session.
    – Volume expanded thus another distribution day.
    – RUT was all along a leading indicator for intraday trading during afternoon session on what to expect for major indices. Dow and NDX-100 were nicely stopped above recent lows. S&P500 was not that fortunate though but still managed to stay above key support level 1,040.
    – Bullish % stocks still below 50%
    – Over 80% of Stocks are trading below 50 day moving average
    – Over 63% of stocks are trading below 200 day moving average, lowest level for the past 52 wks.
    – The breadth indicator that I mentioned in above post hasn’t yet dropped below 0.40

    We should expect a technical rebound tomorrow. On the contrary though, markets are not yet in oversold zone.

  2. […] a week that it was!! It’s very easy to say “just what I said” and pat your shoulder but the tough part is to say now what’s next? How do I benefit from […]

  3. […] breaking the famous Head & Shoulder Pattern that I also talked about, US Markets staged a very strong rally yesterday. The rally was supported by 95% upday. On NYSE, […]

  4. […] what’s the bottom-line: Just like previous Head & Should pattern, this might work out to be a fake one. However, I am going to watch current market move and will […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *